1.7 Introduction to Proofs
Ex: 3, 8, 10, 12, 13
- Direct proof
If is odd, then is odd.
- Contrapositive
If is even, then is even.
- Contradiction
is irrational.
- How to prove "if and only if" statement? ().
- How to prove multiple statements are equivalent? (, and ).
Homework
p112: 13, 26, 27, 31, 32, 42
13. Prove that if is irrational, then is irrational.
Solution
Proof By Contraposition
If is rational, then is rational.
Let , where , and have no common factors. It follows that
As , and have no common factors, is rational.
Therefore, the original statement is true.
26. Prove that if is a positive integer, then is even if and only if is even.
Solution
Let be the statement " is even", and be the statement " is even." To prove the original statement, we need to show and .
1. . Let , where is a positive integer. It follows that
Therefore, is even. is proved.
2. . By contraposition, the contrapositive is "If is odd, then is odd". Let , where is a non-negative integer.
Therefore, is odd. The contrapositive is proved, and is true.
Becuase both and are true, the original statement is true.
27. Prove that if is a positive integer, then is odd if and only if is odd.
Solution
Let be the statement " is odd", and be the statement " is odd." To prove the original statement, we need to show and .
1. . Let , where is a non-negative integer. It follows that
Therefore, is odd. is proved.
2. . By contraposition, If is even, then is even. Let , where is a non-negative integer.
Therefore, is even. is proved.
Becuase both and are true, the original statement is true.
31. Show that these statements about the integer are equivalent: (i) is even, (ii) is odd, (iii) is even.
Solution
Let be the statement (i) is even, be the statement (ii) is odd, and be the statement (iii) is even. In order to show that these statement are equivalent about the integer , we need to show (1), (2), and (3) .
(1) . If (i) is even, then (ii) is odd.
By contraposition, the contrapositive is "if is even, then is odd". Let , where is an integer.
Therefore, is odd. is proved.
(2) . If (ii) is odd, then (iii) is even.
Let , where is an integer.
Therefore, is even. is proved.
(3) . If (iii) is even, then (i) is even.
We first need to proof that if is even, then is even. By contraposition, the contrapositive is "if is odd, then is odd". Let , where is an integer.
Therefore is odd. We proved that if is even, then is even.
Let , where is an integer.
Therefore is even. is proved.
Because (1), (2), and (3) are all true, the statements , , and are equivalent.
32. Show that these statements about the real number are equivalent: (i) is rational, (ii) is rational, (iii) is rational.
Solution
Let be the statement (i) is rational, be the statement (ii) is rational, and be the statement (iii) is rational. In order to show that these statement are equivalent about the real number , we need to show (1), (2), and (3) .
(1) . If (i) is rational, then (ii) is rational.
Let , where and have no common factors and .
Therefore is rational. is proved.
(2) . If (ii) is rational, then (iii) is rational.
Let , where and have no common factors and .
Therefore is rational. is proved.
(3) . If (iii) is rational, then (i) is rational.
Let , where and have no common factors and .
Therefore is rational. is proved.
Because (1), (2), and (3) are all true, the statements , , and are equivalent.
42. Prove that these four statements about the integer are equivalent: (i) is odd, (ii) is even, (iii) is odd, (iv) is even.
Solution
Let be the statement (i) is odd, be the statement (ii) is even, be the statement (iii) is odd, and be the statement (iv) . In order to show that these statement are equivalent about the real number , we need to show (1), (2), (3) , and (4) .
(1) . If (i) is odd, then (ii) is even.
We first need to prove that if is odd, then is odd. By contraposition, the contrapositive is "if is even, then is even." Let , where is an integer.
Therefore, is even. The contrapositive is proved, and the original statement "if is odd, then is odd" is true. Let , where is an integer.
Therefore is even. is proved.
(2) . If (ii) is even, then (iii) is odd.
Let , where is an integer.
Therefore is odd. is proved.
(3) . If (iii) is odd, then (iv) is even.
We first need to prove that if is odd, then is odd.
By contraposition, the contrapositive is "if is even, then is even". Let , where is an integer.
Therefore is even. The statement "if is odd, then is odd" is true.
Let , where is an integer.
Therefore is even. is proved.
(4) . If (iv) is even, then (i) is odd.
We first need to prove that if is even, is odd. By contraposition, the contrapositive is "if is even, then is odd." Let , where is an integer.
Therefore is odd. The statement "if is even, is odd" is true.
Let , where is an integer.
Therefore is odd. is proved.
Because (1), (2), (3) , and (4) are all true, the statements , , , and are equivalent.